Harvard University - GSD (Quilian)



Sep '06 - Dec '09

  • anchor

    CCTV in the MOMA

    Quilian Riano
    Jan 24, '07 7:26 PM EST


    • Darren Hodgson

      +q how did you manage to take those photo's in MoMA, I kept getting shouted at by security guards every time I tried to take a photo, when I was there last November.


      Jan 25, 07 5:40 am  · 


      I didn't notice that you weren't supposed to, so I just took them!

      Jan 25, 07 10:10 am  · 

      that base looks like a rug, which makes it look like a playground... like the buildings are both children and toys, scattered around.

      Jan 25, 07 12:37 pm  · 

      The images on the wall are covered in atrocious cutouts of neon Chinese people, just so you can't see how poorly conceived the interior space is.

      Jan 25, 07 6:45 pm  · 

      i can see that ft, what do you think of that huge atrium they created on the tower side of the boot building? It has potential, but right now it seems like a tall, dark, boring place to be in. Something is off with the scale. I think the foot part of the boot is pretty nicely developed though.

      Jan 25, 07 7:20 pm  · 

      That building must take its shape from the rise and fall of a 3d line graph...modeled in Excel from some esoteric data set?

      Who knows why they made that huge atrium. It does look almost completely without natural light. It seems sensationalist and without justification, and then they stick another big X in the middle of it as if to fudge how uninteresting it is... who knows anymore.. I feel sorry for Beijing. They need buildings that address their real social and environmental problems and they get this messy thing.

      Jan 25, 07 8:45 pm  · 

      I bet Beijing does not feel sorry for you.

      Jan 26, 07 4:59 am  · 

      Are you trying so suggest I should have written, "I feel sorry for the people of Beijing to live in a city filled with examples of the latest trends in popular rock and roll architecture?"

      Or is this a happy little attempt at fending off my cynicism re:China's economic 'miracle'?

      I may never know, Helsinki, if you don't actually make a point.

      Jan 26, 07 5:16 pm  · 

      i saw that exhibit too. i felt like vomiting in there.

      firetruck - a chill pills in the mail.

      Jan 27, 07 7:33 pm  · 

      firetruck my point was just that it's pretty easy to criticize something by saying for example: why build this big expensive building - they should instead solve the huge problems facing the nation.

      Of course, that would be a lot nicer than having a big "messy" building that does not even address environmental/social issues in any way.

      but come on. get real.

      It's a piece of architecture that tackles some questions concerning hierachies, transparency and massmedia. succesfully or not will be proven by the finished project. It's unfair to change criteria and suddenly say it should be green. or socially more aware. or cheaper.

      The CCTV building is in my opinion the most exciting of chinas new developments - most of which is quite bland in the end. It will endure as something to be debated and referred to.

      so yeh. I guess that was my point. and I can't even start to think what a building that would address Chinas real social and environmental problems would be about... Maybe an installation by D&S with a huge cloud of smog that conceals a bunch of red monkeys figting in a cage or something - all in one subtle package. problem solved. great.

      Jan 28, 07 10:59 am  · 

      There's a website that sells a lot of very inexpensive closed caption television (cctv)
      equipment at warehouse prices. <p><p>
      If you know how to set the systems up yourself you can get all the parts from the site
      for cheap: video capture cards, dvrs, cameras, coaxial cables everything.

      I actually put together a 16 camera system myself for way less than if I had hired a
      surveillance company to do it.

      May 14, 07 3:27 pm  · 

      Block this user

      Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?


      This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.

    • Back to Entry List...
  • ×Search in:

Affiliated with:

Authored by:

Other blogs affiliated with Harvard University:

Recent Entries