University of Southern California (Emily)



Aug '08 - Jul '09

  • anchor

    4.5 :: Musings on financial turmoil, beauty, and Chicago

    Emily Kemper
    Feb 10, '09 4:32 PM EST

    Immediately following last week's launch of the Web site that is the product of my thesis research, I started getting feedback from people, which I do appreciate. However, if you didn't fill out a survey, I may not be able to collect your feedback in any kind of formal way for inclusion in my final report, although I will certainly take it into account for any revisions I attempt before my final presentations.

    Another reason for the survey is so I could walk away from it for a bit. Several months of creating something like that, day in and day out, and your head just gets cloudy. So this last week has been my time to unwind a bit, to sort of press my own "reset" button. Naturally a plethora of thoughts has rushed to fill the void once occupied by HTML code, so I will now share some of them with you:

    On financial turmoil:

    I discovered this graph over the weekend, which was produced and released by Speaker Pelosi's office. In case you can't read the fine print, the blue line is jobs lost in 1990's recession, the red line is jobs lost in 2001's recession, and the green line is now. Of course this graph tells us mostly what we already know - that this recession is bad, and it's getting worse for us architects. That article in BD describes a number of large architecture firms who have laid off workers recently, and I have friends at most of them, as I'm sure many of you do as well. Needless to say, I don't need anyone to tell me that it's going to be difficult to find a job after I graduate, even though that doesn't stop people from reminding me constantly. Which is getting a little old.

    On "Worshiping at the Altar of the Almighty Awesome Aesthetic":
    I don't know how or exactly when I came up with this phrase in my head, but I think it's evolved from my view that designers now need to do a lot more than just great design. We have to do great design with a purpose, we have to do it efficiently, we have to communicate with people about why we are doing great design, and we have to learn to live with budgets. And, perhaps, we need to resist the urge to worship at that altar that I mentioned above. You know all this already, but maybe it came up again because of the Neil Denari lecture at USC a couple of weeks ago; Denari is a name that I hear a lot out here, and although I've not met him, he seems like both a brilliant designer and a down-to-earth guy. But I confess watching his slide show with a bit of melancholy - I wanted his innovative designs to DO something. What? I don't know. Transform or something. Like "Optimus Prime Denari" - the building that looks great AND fights crime.

    Neil Denari lecture at USC

    On serendipity:
    After releasing my Web site to the hounds last week, I decided to do something which I seem to never have time for anymore - read a book. Specifically I decided to finish a book I had bought a long time ago but never completed, Devil in the White City. Imagine my surprise when yesterday, while devouring the last half of this book without a break, I began reading the historical accounts of the massive financial distress that the country experienced during the time of the World's Fair and Columbian Exposition in Chicago in 1893. At some point during a break from the book I happened to read Geoff Manaugh's BLDGBLOG where I saw the post, The Boom is Over, with this image of Beijing's TVCC building going up in flames:

    ...and THEN I went back to the book where, as most of you know, the White City, which was once referred to as a "dreamland" for its astounding beauty, went up in flames in 1894 after riots by unemployed workers got out of hand. At this point maybe I am droning on, but does anyone else see parallels here? The late 1800's must have been a rough time for our country: technology was evolving ... the car was being invented ... electric lighting started to appear in buildings. And yet banks were failing, their CEOs committed suicide, unemployment was high, and cities strived to be green and clean. Is it 2009, or is it 1895?

    On my ramblings:
    So I don't entirely know what I'm trying to say except to wonder out loud if there's anything that our profession can learn from our past as we trudge towards a slightly scary and unknown future. Maybe we should all come together again on the banks of Lake Michigan for a new "world's fair" - it's as good a place as any - so we can put our great collective knowledge to use and again produce a futuristic vision of the city, one that is not only aesthetically beautiful but that is sustainable, or biodegradable, or that has buildings that transform to fight crime, etc., etc. One thing I forgot to mention is that even in 1893, although they were unknowingly laying the groundwork for the climate problems we face today, the buildings of the World's Fair "had been designed to maximize the salvage value of their components." When was the last time you designed an entire project so that it could be recycled at the end of its life?

    I will leave you with one of my favorite quotes, which I still think applies today.

    Make no little plans; they have no magic to stir men's blood.
    -Chicago architect and Director of the World's Fair, Daniel H. Burnham


    • I didn't even realize there was a survey the first time i checked out your site.
      Consider myself now surveyed!

      Feb 10, 09 9:22 pm  · 

      aren't most world's fairs designed to be dismantled, re-used, etc? hopefully they are not planned from the start to just sweep all the stuff in the bin (although i guess it wouldn't be such a surprise if that were so).

      the world is a mess. it would be immensely disappointing if all we could come up with was something as superficial and redundant as the aesthetically attractive but otherwise useless city beautiful movement.

      Feb 10, 09 9:29 pm  · 
      vado retro

      The world is fucked up due to the consequences of the big plans. Stay in your rooms people.

      Feb 11, 09 12:18 pm  · 

      Emily, you might find this context helpful regarding Pelosi's statistics:


      Feb 11, 09 1:57 pm  · 

      secretingredient, Hot Air is a notorious right-wing blogging outfit. I appreciate the added context of the many pretty lines on more hard-to-read graphs but am hard pressed to believe anything else they have to say about it.

      Feb 12, 09 12:41 pm  · 

      Emily, yes it is, and Pelosi is a notorious left-wing politician. As a student, I encourage you to look at multiple points of view before forming your opinions. Don't you think your dismissive summation of the historical context as "many pretty lines" is an interesting comment about your own research approach? Indeed, many may find themselves "hard pressed to believe anything else" you have to say about the matter. Good luck this semster.

      Feb 12, 09 1:53 pm  · 

      secretingredient, as a student in my 8th year of university-level architectural education and as a professional with over 7 years of experience, I can assure you that my opinions have already been formed, and it is unlikely that prodding by an anonymous talking screen name in the comments section of my blog is going to change that. The graphs are, in fact, quite nice; I like hard data, and I wouldn't be studying building science if I didn't. None of this changes the fact that we are in the midst of one of the most dire economic situations of my lifetime, and I have no doubt that most readers of my blog understand that my views are in the context of my experiences.

      Feb 12, 09 4:30 pm  · 

      The real problem is that these jobs aren't coming back anytime soon.

      Feb 13, 09 6:18 pm  · 

      Block this user

      Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?


      This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.

    • Back to Entry List...
  • ×Search in:

Affiliated with:

Authored by:

Other blogs affiliated with University of Southern California (USC):

Recent Entries