Jan '05 - Apr '07
I just watched the Lars von Trier/Jorgen Leth documentary The Five Obstructions. It is amazing how similiar the film process is to the architectural process.
In short, von Trier and his creative mentor Leth play a game. Von Trier challenges Leth to remake his film The Perfect Human five times. Each time he gives Leth a set of obstructions. If Leth exposes a weakness, von Trier will punish him with a relevant obstruction. Watching the obstructed creative process is v. interesting.
I want to talk to my Studio Instructors about modeling an assignment on this film. Perhaps each student could be assigned an existing worthy building and have to re-design it with a set of obstructions. Imagine taking Villa Savoye and re-designing using obstructions such as no white, no right angles, the site is downtown etc.
Thoughts?
6 Comments
I completely agree with you. I just showed that film in my history /theory seminar at Cornell, and we talked about it on similar terms. Hihgly underated film... Although I am not sure about mixing 'deconstructing' with 'obstructing'. did you see the Leth original? Great film in its own right.
it has already turned out - it is out.
wow
your idea sounds amazing...
specially for introductory courses... re-do a building with obstructions.
fwiw, originally v. savoy had quite a bit of color all over the joint.
alex - why not just commute to ithaca from columbus every thursday? The seminar is about working methodolgy, called "Working Strategies + Tactics." We are looking at music (serialism), architecture (mat building), film (sequencing), and web (mit media lab, et al)...
Back to 5 Obstructions ... actually what is interesting about Von Trier's method over Leth's is the way in which von Trier operates more from a strategic base and Leth more from a tactical base. Von trier predetermines method as means of testing the outcome, while Leth works more reactively to conditions.
the last obstruction was amazing; von Trier sets up a strategy by which Leth obstructs von Trier without even knowing it. brilliant.
that's interesting
it was the first thing that came into my mind after i saw the movie, that if i ever teach studio i will structure it like this.
my favourites are the original black and white movie about the human and the cartoon one.
Block this user
Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?
Archinect
This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.