Despite having been closed for several years, the pavilion at 12th and Reed remains a much-loved landmark in Passyunk Square, where it is affectionately known as the “Roundhouse.” The contrast between its heavy stone walls and jaunty modernist roof make it unlike anything else in Philadelphia. Until it was eclipsed by a bigger community center in 2005, it was the place where neighborhood residents went to play bocce and take art classes. — The Philadelphia Inquirer
As Philadelphia gets ready to undertake a $2.4 million renovation of the city's Columbus Square park, a curious stone drum topped by a folded plane roof set to be demolished under the plan has caught the public's attention.
Debate over the structure's provenance, particularly, whether the pavilion was designed by pioneering Philadelphia architect Elizabeth Hirsh Fleisher or her business partner Gabriel Roth, has influenced the decision over whether or not to save it. Ultimately, city agencies have decided that the structure is directly attributed to Roth and therefore demolishing it would not erase a woman-designed building. The Philadelphia Inquire architecture critic Inga Saffron is neither convinced by the city's determination over the building's authorship nor by the overall decision to demolish the work, regardless of who is responsible for it.
Defending the structure, Saffron writes, "While we may never know whether a female architect designed this unusual mid-century modern pavilion, it is still deeply entwined with Philadelphia’s history. We don’t need to know everything about the Roundhouse to know that it should be preserved."
1 Comment
Preservation shouldn’t be about identity or even solely the object. It should be about what is being proposed to replace it. If you are just tearing it down for no reason, or replacing it with nothing ... why
Block this user
Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?
Archinect
This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.