Archinect
anchor

Sketching

mszczere
The new generation of architects and students are increasingly becoming worse at sketching and drawing by hand and tend use it much less frequently to share their ideas and are relying much more on cad and photoshop.

In my academic career, I've excelled in architecture school among my peers, (professional career has not been suffering either) though my professors would constantly put pressure on me specifically to sketch out my ideas. Why is this? Why are we so critical of the new generation of architects and their lack of free hand drawing abilities? Isn't it a matter of everyone having their own personal design process? I can always get my ideas and my point across in a number of ways, though sketching is not one of them.

Thoughts?
 
Nov 27, 17 3:34 pm
Non Sequitur

Because a dirty free hand sketch is infinitely sexier than a sketchup rendering. Anyone can paste together something in CAD or CS... 

Nov 27, 17 4:00 pm
JLC-1

a sketch is not "personal design process" - it can convey an idea in 2 seconds; until any digital tool can do that, hand sketching will still be the first option.

Nov 27, 17 4:20 pm
Non Sequitur

Correct. OP is still a student anyways, so I doubt they have seen enough practice to judge how their lack of sketching "process" actually affects their career.

citizen

Yes. A big part of sketching's utility is its immediacy and flexibility. Having to drag out the tablet or laptop and open some software just to put down a quick (but possibly crucial) diagram or two is not practical, or possible sometimes.

And almost anyone can sketch, yes.  But absent the practice of doing it frequently, it may look no better than the client's.  That's not so good.

tintt

If you really want to impress people, sketch upside down across a table from them. It just takes some practice.

Nov 27, 17 4:35 pm
Non Sequitur

...and use either hand interchangeably like it was nothing.

tintt

And write words. My handwriting is actually better when I write upside down.

To really impress them scribble something incomprehensible and tell them how great it is.

The best part is when they nod in agreement even though they haven't got the faintest idea.

tintt

Yeah, that works too. It's all quite a bit easier than we pretend it is.

randomised

Sketching also triggers different parts of the brain, so you might even come up with a (better) solution you'd never even conceptualise when drawing on a computer. There is something magical happening when you put a pen or pencil on a piece of paper and start scribbling. Also, how do you scribble in CAD? That being said, I'm horrible at sketching and whatever I sketch is often out of proportion, generally ugly and not meant to be flaunted or seduce clients with. It is a personal design and engineering tool for me that helps me clarify my thoughts and identify problems and solutions.

Nov 27, 17 9:42 pm
jamesaleisterbarcelona

I wish I was better at sketching (and hand drafting).  Most clients don't appreciate it as much now. They like hyper-realistic renderings because it gives them a more realistic look and feel of the project. A hand sketch rendered with color pencils or markers or water color still wins for me. Like this one:

Nov 27, 17 10:16 pm
randomised

I wouldn't be surprised if that was a traced computer drawing ;)

jamesaleisterbarcelona

Haha! I would think this was digitally sketched (not something drawn on paper then scanned), but I just love the texture, the shading and the crookedness of it. I've always thought how hand-drawn plans, sketches and renderings keep that sensation of fantasy in there. And it's also so easy to look at or smooth in the eyes. Also, back in the day (because i don't think it's the same as now), having the actual skill and talent to draw by hand was deemed an advantage or must-have if you wanted to be an architect/designer because it was always a foundation skill one must have to pursue this profession.

randomised

I used to love drawing as a kid and was pretty good at it, even won some awards etc. but being forced to work too much on the computer not only made my handwriting look like from a drunk doctor with Parkinson's (no offense) it also did a number on my sketching skills...I do however always carry a notebook and some pens and pencils and scribble. I think I even got hired once because I went to the interview with a fat roll of tracing paper sticking nonchalantly out of my bag, they knew I wasn't kidding around haha.

I definitely trace computer models. Still my preferred method of designing because I can go through a bunch of options fairly quickly. It is a valuable tool to have in your arsenal.

Eye-hand coordination, the basis for all human development, entirely lacking with computers.

Keep sketching and you will get better. Life drawing classes help a lot - with drawing and more so with seeing.

Nov 27, 17 10:16 pm
jamesaleisterbarcelona

"Eye-hand coordination, the basis for all human development, entirely lacking with computers." So true. It's like no camera can ever replicate what the naked eye can see.

citizen

It's not only eye-level renderings, but don't forget diagrams, plans, sections, elevations, details... all the 2D stuff.

Nov 27, 17 11:06 pm
ArchAli

Personally, I think there's a lack of understanding in the development of technology in the older generation of architects. These days there's the possibility of drawing using your phone and even computer with a drawing tablet.

In saying that there's a benefit in drawing with your hands as an architect there's a thinking process that develops in the mind when you settle and take the time to draw.


Nov 29, 17 9:22 pm
williamhines

I fond of drawing! The best thing is making my imagination turn into a real thing, a piece where it only came to my mind and no one did. I like drawing ever since a child, I want to elaborate things to let them see my perspective.

When I didn't find the drawings I really want to see, I draw them. Even though it turns out different than I imagine sometimes but in the end, I still enjoy its company.

Making characters and see how they go through their lives, drawing things to view what is your perspective and how you'll change or keeping it like it was what you viewed.

Learning new things, and observed the surroundings.

I love drawing because I know in the future, I'll see it with my own eyes the picture I've always imagined and I can keep going and grow further.

Feb 8, 19 1:56 pm
chigurh

Hand sketching allows you to work through ideas in a loose and free manner, not constrained by the (often) limited tools available in software.  Buildings that are the direct result of a software tool constraint are sad...the push pull in sketch-up is primary aesthetic driver for most of the terrible developer modern buildings from the early 2000's to present.  


Feb 10, 19 10:59 pm

Block this user


Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?

  • ×Search in: