Archinect
anchor

Midwest schools

abcanthur

Essentially this post is requesting opinions on Illinois Institute of Technology and University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee.

I applied to a handful of architecture programs this last fall very last minute (decided to apply December 15th) and luckily met with good success going 4.5/5 (UI-Chicago, IIT, Notre Dame, UW-Milwaukee, wait-listed UWashington (Seattle, not St Louis)). I am coming from a totally unrelated field and don't know much about schools. I got decent financial offers at all these schools, so I'm kind of figuring that I probably have a decent shot of getting into a better school than any of these. My grades aren't great, but I went to an Ivy, have near perfect GREs, can write very well, and I figure any portfolio I make will be better than the one I pulled out of my @$$ in two weeks last January. Already said no to ND and UIC, so now I'm deciding between UWM and IIT. The plan would be to apply again this December to more schools (simply missed the deadlines, and didn't have a few pre-reqs for a lot of them). So for one year, where would you go, UWM for 5k or IIT for 15k??
(I'm from Milwaukee, but I live in Chicago)

Are there any general opinions on these schools against each other, and any comments on my specific situation?

Thanks for your help! I'm new to the architecture world so my level of knowledge is pretty low.

 
Apr 26, 10 3:20 pm
w4000

I would first check to see if any of the m. arch options you are considering would even accept transfer credits.

Apr 26, 10 4:12 pm  · 
 · 
abcanthur

not planning on transferring, already checked, would apply totally fresh as a first year applicant. Some schools said I may be able to pass out of courses, which would just give me more electives at the next school, which I view as a plus.

Apr 26, 10 4:16 pm  · 
 · 
DisplacedArchitect

Go to IIT,

and dont take the studios with the crazy designy professors, aka (easy studios), take studios with mies's ex students before the dean pisses them off and they all retire.

good luck

Apr 26, 10 5:58 pm  · 
 · 
blah

LiveLoad,

Which of the old Mies guys are left?

I got one involved on a project with Giannoulias. It didn't go anywhere but I realized how much I have grown and changed since school. And for the better...

Apr 26, 10 6:18 pm  · 
 · 
mantaray
not planning on transferring, already checked, would apply totally fresh as a first year applicant.

Why would you do this at all? This sounds like a total waste of money. Arch school is very expensive, as you can tell from reading this board...

Apr 26, 10 10:22 pm  · 
 · 
DisplacedArchitect

Hi Make,
my professors were all either students of Mies, some of my other professors were not directly taught by Mies, but they were all very good professors. I know Professor Sharpe recently retired. Its too bad the college lost one of its treasures. Well Make, there are Professor's Takeuchi, Karaidis, Beltemacchi (taught by Hilbsheimer), Schippreit (whom im not sure was a student but he did know Mies), Roesch, There are others, let me be clear. You will get the most out of IIT if you work hard enough and have an open mind. IIT was the best architecture experience while i was there, Its program was flexible enough to accommodate students that wanted to get into other experimental theory, or we could go take studios where we learn more than just theory, but how to make a good building.

Make, you got to remember not all these veterans want to do anymore charity work or public work, they have been there and done that, now they just want to teach. Id recommend you go talk to the younger professors that still feel they have something to prove.

Anyways its good that you have grown, and changed since college. Why do people call it School? we payed way too much to say school.

What college did you go to? are you an architect Make?

And Make of course we all change, but the foundation you build at IIT will always serve you.




Apr 27, 10 12:56 am  · 
 · 
chicagoarchitect

So simple - UWM. Lower cost, lower living expenses in Milwaukee, safer neighborhood and nicer ambience, and likely comparable school studio experience for only one year of architectural school. After two months, you'll know if you want to transfer out, stay, or quit architecture altogether.

It really doesn't matter where you go to school, once you've graduated. But ask both school admissions offices where their graduates work, and ask to speak to several recent grads.

I'm surprised that the "Mies student" professors are still at IIT; they must be very old at this point. Their rote instruction of Mies' design idiom was largely simple duplication of Mies' design motifs.

Apr 27, 10 6:15 pm  · 
 · 
DisplacedArchitect

abcanthur,
College, is just one step, but having worked in this profession more than a few years now, i do think it matters what kind of professors you have, never mind the Cheap shot that chicagoarchitect took at IIT, its something i have gotten used to through out the years, kind of envy or jelousy i dont know, some people wish they went to IIT.

Apr 27, 10 7:42 pm  · 
 · 
DisplacedArchitect

wherever you go read books, and not just any contemporary books on random stuff email me ill give you a list if your interested.

Apr 27, 10 7:53 pm  · 
 · 

First, I agree with manta: in some ways this seems like a waste of money.

But you also need to think strategically. Your portfolio a year from now will contain projects from a school you are choosing to leave. Let's say you're applying to Harvard: what would they think of a student who is abandoning IIT vs. UWM? Or the bigger question: will leaving a school, any school, to pursue another reflect positively or negatively on your application?

Apr 27, 10 11:28 pm  · 
 · 
DisplacedArchitect

Harvard arch. is no good.

Apr 27, 10 11:49 pm  · 
 · 
chicagoarchitect

Live Load: I've a B Arch from IIT.

Apr 29, 10 1:21 pm  · 
 · 
DisplacedArchitect

So, chicagoarchitect, Why did you stay at IIT for 5 years before you figured out you hated Mies and his old students?

Shame on you Chicago Architect, bashing your own almamater, you must have been one of those crazy design students who thought the sun rose and set around them each morning. Why did you go to IIT anyway? probably just got a better financial deal or something? just wondering ive heard so many reasons why unhappy IIT students are there, and it comes down to that they are there by some dumb luck.

Apr 29, 10 4:12 pm  · 
 · 
modelcitizen

Can anyone speak on Notre Dame and how their graduates do in the job hunt after graduation?

It seems like Notre Dame is usually dismissed or ignored entirely in most discussions...

Sep 22, 10 5:26 pm  · 
 · 

Block this user


Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?

Archinect


This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.

  • ×Search in: