* 1 1/2 years work experience at two architecture firms, one graphic design firm (MSKTD, SmithgroupJJR)
* Worked for a few months in Turkey as a Site Architect. (Harvard Art Museums)
* Traveled on a World Tour program to 27 countries to study design/art/architecture
@ Philip:
That's really nice work. It looks both constructable and tastefully laid out. In which years did you do this work? I'm assuming it would be more in years 3 and 4. With which programs did you do the graphics? Is part of that work done in an office?
As for the schools, I'd say you have a good shot at all of them. The only one that's trickier would be Berkeley, since they are dealing with massive numbers.
The one thing I can't comment on is, for 4 year grads, if they need to show other forms of creative expression. I know that for 3/3.5 M.Archs. they almost get pissed if you present anything along the line of architectural graphics if you haven't worked in it before, sort of as in "How dare you?"
Thanks I appreciate the compliment. Most of the work was done in my 3 and 4 years, with exception of 1 project I think. For renders I used Rhino and V-ray and a lot of photoshop. For line drawings I used AutoCAD and illustrator/photoshop. None of the work was done in an office.
I included that one spread of photos and travel sketches b/c most schools said they would like to see other creative work. I wish I had more creative work outside of strict architecture work but I can only show what I've got hah so it'll have to do.
@turg - I have a deadline right now so I can't comment too extensively, but you have some interesting work which maybe isn't always presented with the best graphic design composition. If you redid some of your presentations to have more hierarchy and fewer more carefully-selected images you would be in a good position.
@snail - I appreciate the advice. I agree with you - my portfolio does look a bit crowded and over the top. Sadly all my applications are already submitted and there's nothing else to do about it but wait... I'll keep it in mind when I re-edit them for different purposes. Thanks!
@ turq your work is brilliant. You will probably get accepted to a lot of places. I teach 2nd year design studio and I am embarassed to even show some of your work to my students because they would feel humiliated. If you had to choose on your list right now, which would you choose and why?
I just sent out a last-minute application to Cooper Union. Not many people seem to be applying there on this thread - why?
Also, at what point do we start the "Decisions 2013 MArch" Thread??
@mtt9999 Cooper Union only has March II and it's a really new program. Not many people know about it. I wish they had an March I program. It's a dream school.
I'm hoping to start posting in the new thread mid march.
@turq I'd like to know where you want to go as well.
@jholguin71 - Thanks. I see you're applying this year too - good luck!
@mtt9999 - Wow you're saying that for real? I'm simply grateful. I haven't shown my work to many people except for some close friends/professors and it's really nice to receive positive comments from people who are actually applying this year. As for your question, I don't think I'm in a position to be picky yet. GSD and YSOA are my dream schools - not only by the name-value but for the faculty/educational resources which seem to be sublime. But who knows...
@disro - Yes, I think it's early to be choosing schools and after crazy months of waiting I'm in the mindset of receiving any admission gladly. But GSD and YSOA would be rosy.
Hey I'm late to this thread but wanted to get some portfolio feedback. I've never studied design but applying to M.Arch programs and not too sure what to expect.
@jacobcohen I'd get rid of page 8. I really like pages 18 and 19 as well as your glass blowing images. I would work on the layout and order of the portfolio more. I'd start with a strong image and end with a strong image. Also, I'd keep the same color background throughout the entire portfolio. Being consistent and clear is key.I don't find it necessary to have a different colored line under each title, it's a little distracting. What if you start with the Artist's Book page, I think it works really well. It would be a good way to introduce your portfolio (as your own artist's book)
Good luck. Where are you applying? If you have already applied with that portfolio, I wouldn't worry too much. You seem like you have a good eye for design and a good hand-that's all that matters.
@disro Thanks for the feedback.... I did already apply but good pointers, those are things i probably would have looked at further if I had more time. Still one application to go so might make some changes.
Unfortunately for me, everything is so messed up in my country that i didnt get the chance to take the GRE, and so am taking another year off. may be i will see some of you guys next year.
@A.R.Ch
your portfolio is great - it is organaized and nice and the projects are also eye catching. maybe the texts are sometimes too much, but that would be the only draw back. i wont be surprised to hear that you've got in all these schools. good luck.
@philip
your work is also really nice. thanks for sharing it. :)
@ A.R.Ch. I too am applying for the Yale MED program. I'm concerned about how tough it is to get in, only about 4-5 per year. When you submitted your portfolio to the MED program did you submit the pdf you linked (with design work), or did you submit just your sample writings? I only submitted sample published writings because it is only a research degree, but I feel like I should have also submitted some of my design work. Your portfolio looks really nice - would you mind sharing your research proposal? I would love to read it. I will try to get mine posted here (need to finally join issuu)
nice portfolio man. your choice of schools has me puzzled, though. I can totally see you going to Yale... but Upenn and MIT have me scratching my head. They are really focused on computation and fabrication.
@A.R.Ch I think you have one of the most visually pleasing portfolios I have seen on here. Clear, thorough, great drawings, lovely tone. Good luck, hopefully we'll bump into each other in Rudolph's halls next year.
shiv, mtt, jk3hl, disro: thanks for the comments, and good luck with your applications.
@mtt: I submitted a research proposal and examples of published articles in addition to my portfolio, and decided to include the design work due to the nature of my proposal. I'd be happy to share my proposed abstract in an email.
@jk3hl: As I'm focusing on research oriented degrees, the stereotype of each school matters less than the faculty members with whom I hope to work, as well as each school's support for independently driven research. For example, despite UPenn's general fascination with computation, David Leatherbarrow works with the MS Arch students.
@A.R.Ch: Excellent sounds like a wonderful application and proposal. Best of luck to you - I hope to see you there in the fall! All things being equal (mostly money), if you had to choose between the programs is there one in particular that interests you the most? Is the MIT and Penn Research programs 2 years like YALE's MED?
bringing this thread back up.. could those who got accepted please post again perhaps with the portfolio you used.. it would help us future applicants get an idea of the work the different schools are looking for . :)
Caveat: I am not a BArch or MArch student, but I was just accepted to GSAPP.
I loved your portfolio and think you should apply to higher end schools. Your portfolio is extremely tasteful and full of a diverse range of work and is bent on the practical side too. With an excellent GRE score, there is no reason why you couldn't get in somewhere.
From just a presentation point of view, I like your title pages a lot because of the white space and feel that some of the spreads are overcrowded with images. If you can lay them out more strategically I think it can benefit the portfolio.
I looked through it twice. I think it's better than most of the one's I've seen on here. First, I notice that you sequenced your projects by studio IN ORDER. I think the side-by-side of process, elements, and finished projects looks great. I like that you tastefully inserted professional work toward the end without interrupting the flow of the portfolio. Not only that, your freehand work is good, shows a different side of your abilities, and also works in fluidly without creating a hiccup. Detailed but understated portfolio.
The only thing I did not like was the local flavor - not in the projects, but in a couple of photo stills which look very "Montana." I would insert something else onto those pages, preferably something related to the built environment, even if a snippet of something that doesn't identify a building as a whole, but is appealing to you. Since it appears you are in Chicago, there should be plenty to choose from.
I think you have an easy shot at all those schools, and should apply to even more highly ranked schools.
This just made my day! Thank you, for the time you took to look at my portfolio. I just moved from Montana to Chicago and have been unable to find an internship for nearly 5 months. This really got to my head and I have lost some confidence in myself. I found a Summer Internship in Wyoming, so I'm just waiting until then. Currently, I am working for a moving company. It's a very sad experience, thus far. I feel as though I need to get an M.Arch from a better school then Montana, otherwise nobody will consider me in Chicago. My family is in Chicago, so this is where I would like to be. I honestly, wasn't going to send to GSAPP. Thanks for the encouragement, once again.
@Kamueku Luke Kakizaki and @turq I remember your portfolios more than anyone else's. I've been wondering why you've disappeared. I hope you got into the schools you were hoping for!
2013 APPLICANTS PREP
mtt9999:
Thank you for your interest in my projects!
Please check your inbox for my email (from lemanh17@gmail.com).
Best regards.
Hello everyone, Late to the thread!
22/Female
BS Honors Architecture ~3.5/4.0
BFA Visual Communications 3.71/4.0
* 1 1/2 years work experience at two architecture firms, one graphic design firm (MSKTD, SmithgroupJJR)
* Worked for a few months in Turkey as a Site Architect. (Harvard Art Museums)
* Traveled on a World Tour program to 27 countries to study design/art/architecture
Applying to:
Yale
GSD
Columbia
RISD
University of Michigan
University of Maryland
Arizona State
Clemson
Berkeley
University of Illinois
Portfolio: http://www.issuu.com/eemcgowan/docs/designportfolio
CV: 100%
Recom.: 4 Professors (Art and Architecture) , Directors, Professionals from internships
Please leave me your feedback regarding the portfolio! Any input/advice would be great.
I wish I had known about this thread when I was making my portfolio.
Oh well it's already done.
BS Architecture from Univ. of Florida
Applying to
Oregon-Portland
Berkeley
Univ Florida
Univ washington
IIT
http://issuu.com/philipmp88/docs/cal-portfolio
Is anyone else applying to the Portland program at Univ of Oregon? Thats probably my #1 right now.
@ Philip:
That's really nice work. It looks both constructable and tastefully laid out. In which years did you do this work? I'm assuming it would be more in years 3 and 4. With which programs did you do the graphics? Is part of that work done in an office?
As for the schools, I'd say you have a good shot at all of them. The only one that's trickier would be Berkeley, since they are dealing with massive numbers.
The one thing I can't comment on is, for 4 year grads, if they need to show other forms of creative expression. I know that for 3/3.5 M.Archs. they almost get pissed if you present anything along the line of architectural graphics if you haven't worked in it before, sort of as in "How dare you?"
I wish you the best.
@observant
Thanks I appreciate the compliment. Most of the work was done in my 3 and 4 years, with exception of 1 project I think. For renders I used Rhino and V-ray and a lot of photoshop. For line drawings I used AutoCAD and illustrator/photoshop. None of the work was done in an office.
I included that one spread of photos and travel sketches b/c most schools said they would like to see other creative work. I wish I had more creative work outside of strict architecture work but I can only show what I've got hah so it'll have to do.
Hey guys, this is my first time at Archinect :)
Having a hard time waiting it out... hope this helps!
24/Female
B.Arch @ Hanyang Univ. of Korea
GPA: 3.76/4.00 (summa cum laude)
GRE: 159/164/3.5
+ Several work experiences related to architecture, but none notable
+ Also several awards, honorable mentions...etc
+ 4 recommendation letters from professors who know me well
http://issuu.com/garamhann/docs/portfolio
Applying to:
GSD
Yale
GSAPP
MIT
Cornell
UC Berkeley
Any portfolio critique would be welcome. Even though all the applications are finished... honestly I think I need some advice.
@turq you're going to get accepted at every school and you'll find it hard to make a decision. Good luck!
@e.m.g I love your portfolio. RISD would be great!
Hi late as well
28/ Male
B.A. Studio Art @ U of TN Knoxville
Gpa: 3.1
Gre: 150V / 150 Q
Portfolio: http://issuu.com/israelceja/docs/whatever
Applied to
Oregon
U of Washington
Cornell
@disro - Thanks for the compliment! Good luck to you as well.
@turg - I have a deadline right now so I can't comment too extensively, but you have some interesting work which maybe isn't always presented with the best graphic design composition. If you redid some of your presentations to have more hierarchy and fewer more carefully-selected images you would be in a good position.
@snail - I appreciate the advice. I agree with you - my portfolio does look a bit crowded and over the top. Sadly all my applications are already submitted and there's nothing else to do about it but wait... I'll keep it in mind when I re-edit them for different purposes. Thanks!
@turq - Your portfolio looks great! Good luck!
@cizz - Good art and photographs. Good luck as well.
@ turq your work is brilliant. You will probably get accepted to a lot of places. I teach 2nd year design studio and I am embarassed to even show some of your work to my students because they would feel humiliated. If you had to choose on your list right now, which would you choose and why?
I just sent out a last-minute application to Cooper Union. Not many people seem to be applying there on this thread - why?
Also, at what point do we start the "Decisions 2013 MArch" Thread??
@mtt9999 Cooper Union only has March II and it's a really new program. Not many people know about it. I wish they had an March I program. It's a dream school.
I'm hoping to start posting in the new thread mid march.
@turq I'd like to know where you want to go as well.
@jholguin71 - Thanks. I see you're applying this year too - good luck!
@mtt9999 - Wow you're saying that for real? I'm simply grateful. I haven't shown my work to many people except for some close friends/professors and it's really nice to receive positive comments from people who are actually applying this year. As for your question, I don't think I'm in a position to be picky yet. GSD and YSOA are my dream schools - not only by the name-value but for the faculty/educational resources which seem to be sublime. But who knows...
@disro - Yes, I think it's early to be choosing schools and after crazy months of waiting I'm in the mindset of receiving any admission gladly. But GSD and YSOA would be rosy.
Hey I'm late to this thread but wanted to get some portfolio feedback. I've never studied design but applying to M.Arch programs and not too sure what to expect.
24/M
BA. Geography and Art History, McGill University
GPA: 3.44 overall / 3.67 Program
GRE: 162 verbal / 156 Quant
http://issuu.com/jacobleecohen/docs/portfolio?mode=window
@jacobcohen I'd get rid of page 8. I really like pages 18 and 19 as well as your glass blowing images. I would work on the layout and order of the portfolio more. I'd start with a strong image and end with a strong image. Also, I'd keep the same color background throughout the entire portfolio. Being consistent and clear is key.I don't find it necessary to have a different colored line under each title, it's a little distracting. What if you start with the Artist's Book page, I think it works really well. It would be a good way to introduce your portfolio (as your own artist's book)
Good luck. Where are you applying? If you have already applied with that portfolio, I wouldn't worry too much. You seem like you have a good eye for design and a good hand-that's all that matters.
@disro Thanks for the feedback.... I did already apply but good pointers, those are things i probably would have looked at further if I had more time. Still one application to go so might make some changes.
Applying to Canadian and US schools:
Carleton
University of Toronto
UBC
Cornell
Penn Design
GSD
Wash U in St. Louis
Boston Arch College
25/M
B.Arch University of Tennessee
-4 internships across the Southeast US
-2 years professional experience at a large design firm in Atlanta
-1 year teaching studio at Georgia Tech
Applying to:
Yale (M.E.D)
MIT (SMarchS Architecture)
UPenn (MS Architecture)
Portfolio
Unfortunately for me, everything is so messed up in my country that i didnt get the chance to take the GRE, and so am taking another year off. may be i will see some of you guys next year.
@A.R.Ch
your portfolio is great - it is organaized and nice and the projects are also eye catching. maybe the texts are sometimes too much, but that would be the only draw back. i wont be surprised to hear that you've got in all these schools. good luck.
@philip
your work is also really nice. thanks for sharing it. :)
@ A.R.Ch. I too am applying for the Yale MED program. I'm concerned about how tough it is to get in, only about 4-5 per year. When you submitted your portfolio to the MED program did you submit the pdf you linked (with design work), or did you submit just your sample writings? I only submitted sample published writings because it is only a research degree, but I feel like I should have also submitted some of my design work. Your portfolio looks really nice - would you mind sharing your research proposal? I would love to read it. I will try to get mine posted here (need to finally join issuu)
Best of luck to all of you
@ARCh
nice portfolio man. your choice of schools has me puzzled, though. I can totally see you going to Yale... but Upenn and MIT have me scratching my head. They are really focused on computation and fabrication.
@A.R.Ch I think you have one of the most visually pleasing portfolios I have seen on here. Clear, thorough, great drawings, lovely tone. Good luck, hopefully we'll bump into each other in Rudolph's halls next year.
shiv, mtt, jk3hl, disro: thanks for the comments, and good luck with your applications.
@mtt: I submitted a research proposal and examples of published articles in addition to my portfolio, and decided to include the design work due to the nature of my proposal. I'd be happy to share my proposed abstract in an email.
@jk3hl: As I'm focusing on research oriented degrees, the stereotype of each school matters less than the faculty members with whom I hope to work, as well as each school's support for independently driven research. For example, despite UPenn's general fascination with computation, David Leatherbarrow works with the MS Arch students.
@A.R.Ch: Excellent sounds like a wonderful application and proposal. Best of luck to you - I hope to see you there in the fall! All things being equal (mostly money), if you had to choose between the programs is there one in particular that interests you the most? Is the MIT and Penn Research programs 2 years like YALE's MED?
I have applied to the following:
YALE MED
Harvard GSD MDesS
McGill MPhil in Arch
Cooper Union MArchII
my email is matt.teismann@lionarchitecture.com
bringing this thread back up.. could those who got accepted please post again perhaps with the portfolio you used.. it would help us future applicants get an idea of the work the different schools are looking for . :)
I would love your opinion.
I plan to apply to a Graduate Program in the next Year.
BA Environmental Design
Internship: 1 (will have another this Summer)
GPA: 3.1
GRE: -
Portfolio: http://issuu.com/jakubgalczynski/docs/galczynski
Does anyone think I have a chance at GSAPP, Texas A&M or Pratt?
I'm going to apply to a few safety schools, nevertheless. Thank You for the honest opinions.
Any suggestions on the portfolio, would also be appreciated.
Jakub,
Caveat: I am not a BArch or MArch student, but I was just accepted to GSAPP.
I loved your portfolio and think you should apply to higher end schools. Your portfolio is extremely tasteful and full of a diverse range of work and is bent on the practical side too. With an excellent GRE score, there is no reason why you couldn't get in somewhere.
Thank you jesusmaldonado for the confidence. If anyone has criticism or suggestions, this would be much appreciated.
From just a presentation point of view, I like your title pages a lot because of the white space and feel that some of the spreads are overcrowded with images. If you can lay them out more strategically I think it can benefit the portfolio.
Jakub:
I looked through it twice. I think it's better than most of the one's I've seen on here. First, I notice that you sequenced your projects by studio IN ORDER. I think the side-by-side of process, elements, and finished projects looks great. I like that you tastefully inserted professional work toward the end without interrupting the flow of the portfolio. Not only that, your freehand work is good, shows a different side of your abilities, and also works in fluidly without creating a hiccup. Detailed but understated portfolio.
The only thing I did not like was the local flavor - not in the projects, but in a couple of photo stills which look very "Montana." I would insert something else onto those pages, preferably something related to the built environment, even if a snippet of something that doesn't identify a building as a whole, but is appealing to you. Since it appears you are in Chicago, there should be plenty to choose from.
I think you have an easy shot at all those schools, and should apply to even more highly ranked schools.
@observant
@AvanineCommuter
@ jesusmaldonado
This just made my day! Thank you, for the time you took to look at my portfolio. I just moved from Montana to Chicago and have been unable to find an internship for nearly 5 months. This really got to my head and I have lost some confidence in myself. I found a Summer Internship in Wyoming, so I'm just waiting until then. Currently, I am working for a moving company. It's a very sad experience, thus far. I feel as though I need to get an M.Arch from a better school then Montana, otherwise nobody will consider me in Chicago. My family is in Chicago, so this is where I would like to be. I honestly, wasn't going to send to GSAPP. Thanks for the encouragement, once again.
if i can get into gsapp there is no reason why you shouldn't. i think you should aim for gsd and ysoa
@Kamueku Luke Kakizaki and @turq I remember your portfolios more than anyone else's. I've been wondering why you've disappeared. I hope you got into the schools you were hoping for!
Block this user
Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?
Archinect
This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.