by Martina Dolejsova
Overview:
The entire city of Venice is activated by the Biennale with multiple pavillions sprouting up in museums and gallery spaces. The two main spaces (needing a ticket) are at the Arsenale and the Giardini. The Arsenale, a building that was historically dedicated to shipbuilding and the making of ropes for ships, holds thirty exhibitors expanding along the linear building with eight additional international pavillions that have been invited into the space. The Giardini is the home to thirty international pavillions each with their own number of architects exhibiting, including the large Italian Pavillion with 56 architects showing a multitude of installations, presentations and explosions. The exhibition is running from September 14 to November 23, 2008
Review:
Directly surrounding me are architects Deborah Gans (Gans Studio), Benjamin Ball (Ball-Nogues Studio), Laurent Gutierrez and Val�rie Portefaix (MAP Office) who have taken the seat to play with meanings. A few days prior to the opening of the Venice Biennale: 'Out There: Architecture Beyond Building', I grabbed a chair from the interior of the Dutch Pavillion, a cubed transparent plastic container that was forming the walls, while others created tables and drank wine with laughter at a hosted dinner for all participants. The discourse has already begun and Gans hit a resonating idea that rings in my ears as I walk through the event during the opening days; "The word building is both a noun and a verb and subsequently an object and an action. We are always in a state of 'building'. The idea is to leave the object but not the act of making. It should be renamed, 'Building Beyond Architecture'." - Deborah Gans
Ball-Nogues Studio
Unseen current
2008, 3000 catenarie, stampa a getto d�inchiostro su maglia. 7,5 x 5 x 4 m, Extension Gallery, Chicago Illinois, USA, Photo: Michelle Litvin, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
MAP Office
Underneath: Giocare di notte 2 / Underneath: playing at night 2
Guangzhou, Cina 2005, Dettaglio, fotografia, 17 x 11,5 cm, � MAP Office, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
The Venice Biennale succeeded in overwhelming the heady assumptions of being 'out there'. The reaching arms of architecture of experiementation into the digital world, the fields of science, fabrication, urbanity, and social responsibilities were represented to the point of numbing the mind.
Entering into the Italian Pavillion at the Giardini does not prepare you for the mishmash of projects that you stumble into. You are eased in by J�rgen Mayer H. 's numeric wallpaper leading to the opening of a bamboo construction of highly crafted chairs acting as joints foresting the space. This installation designed by Herzog & DeMeuron and Ai Weiwei, brought the skill and craftsmen of Chinese farmers who use woodworking in the everyday. This fascinating and pleasurable display came as a result from the interactions of H+DM during their stay in China for the construction of their famous Bird's Nest Building at the 2008 Olympics.
J�rgen Mayer H. Architects
pre.text / vor.wand
2008, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
From that room a maze of disjointed exhibits are filling walls and floors as if consumption was the design criteria. Before feeling almost hopeless in this menagerie, the punching bag assisted video game provided by Collectif Exyzt materializes in the next room. Each hit tears down an adjacent plasma screened building with the fun of a Wii. It works out the frustrations of constantly asking yourself, "What am I looking at? What does this mean?" Last I saw, the high score was 286 hits.
This is where there is a disservice for there are wonderful examples like Rectas Urbanas housing solutions, J,P:A Jones Partners Architecture , Stefano Boeri 's film of urban ecologies, and exhibits well worth spending the better part of an hour like in Madelon Vriesendorp 's collection of objects and paintings. What is needed are the spaces for contemplation and pause in this thought induced environment. The glue that holds the show together (perhaps the graphic Thonik designed wall border) fails as a theme to allow the mind to understand how it all relates to architecture.
Recetas Urbanas
Cartel UH
Photo: � Recetas Urbanas, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
J,P:A Jones Partners Architecture
(Wes Jones, con Mary Aramian, Jennifer Dinardo, Necmi Karaman, Ming Cheng Chang)
La vista / The View
Dubai, 2008, Disegno digitale, 21,6 x 35,6 cm, Courtesy: the Author and Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Boeri Studio
Torre ZIP
2008, Padova, Italia, � Boeri Studio, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Madelon Vriesendorp
Ecstasy of Mrs Caligari, 1973
Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Thonik
Graphic Tapestries
Installazione site specific per l�11. Mostra Internazionale di Architettura � La Biennale di Venezia, Photo: Stefano Graziani, � La Biennale di Venezia
In escaping to the other Pavillions, Poland (Nicolas Grospierre , Kobas Laksa), winner of the Golden Lion Award for the Best National Participation, juxtoposes built structures and a possible 2050 future through photography and digital manipulation. Imagine a Skidmore, Owings and Merrill designed glass and steel building transformed into a dystopic, gotham city revival of a factory hiding under a massive future highway system. Thinking beyond the archictecture.
Or thinking about the architecture, like the France, Australian and Chile Pavillions (Chile found in the Arsenale) that showed models which uniquely fit the scaled forms into a defined restriction. Slick bubbles held the models of France, whereas Austrailia displayed around 300 differenet architects with the broad range of architectural ideas, experiemental and physical fitting roughly onto a one foot diameter disc. I found these to provide a genial presentation of discovery and enjoyment in representations of built and unbuilt work.
Next, the country with no pavillion, Estonia (Maarja Kask, Neeme Kulm, Ralf Looke), that obscurs the walkway with a neon yellow painted structure: a gas pipeline. Like it or not, this pipe represents the struggle of construction and economy all over the world, highlighting the need of good design and consideration. Cameras inside transmit live to screens in the Arsenale and without knowing it, you've metaphysically made the leap to the other main site of the Biennale.
Zaha Hadid Architects
La torre Tatlin e il Tektonic �Worldwind�
The Great Utopia, esposizione al Museo Guggenheim, New York 1992, Acrilico e colori ad acqua su cartridge, 177 x 101 cm, � Zaha Hadid Architects, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Zaha Hadid Architects
Lotus
2008, Photo Giorgio Zucchiatti, � Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Frank Gehry
Schizzo per il Museo della Tolleranza
� Gehry Partners, LLP, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Frank Gehry
Ungapatchket
2008, Photo Giorgio Zucchiatti, � Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
COOP HIMMELB(L)AU
Feedback Space
Installazione site specific per l�11. Mostra Internazionale di Architettura � La Biennale di Venezia, Photo: Stefano Graziani, � La Biennale di Venezia
Asymptote: Hani Rashid + Lise Anne Couture
Prototyping the Future: Three Houses for the Subconscious
2008, Installazione site specific per l�11. Mostra Internazionale di Architettura � La Biennale di Venezia, Photo: Stefano Graziani, � La Biennale di Venezia
Making your way down the into and down the Arsenale, past Zaha Hadid 's forms and Frank Gehry 's cracked clay curves, you'll walk past M-A-D's (Erik Adigard and Chris Salter) interactive digital screen, a confusing contemplation that addresses an experimental look at the qualities of surviellance in the environment. Who dares interact with it? It is an extremely powerful and fascinating study to people watch and develop an understanding of this post 9/11 world (yes, i'm still using that term). It is too bad you need someone to explain that to you as Salter did with me, eventually intriquing me enough to stay and observe others with it for a small time. If you continue walking, you'll run into Philippe Rahm Architects sensual hot and cold installation, Greg Lynn 's tables, Diller Scofidio + Renfro and the next string of hosted international pavillions.
Syd Matters
Performance
September 10th-12th 2008, Philippe Rahm�s Installation, Photo Giorgio Zucchiatti, � Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Greg Lynn FORM
Recycled Toy Furniture
2008, Photo Giorgio Zucchiatti, � Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
DILLER SCOFIDIO + RENFRO
Chain City
2008, Courtesy: DILLER SCOFIDIO + RENFRO and Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Worth seeing, if you can survive the trek, is the landscaped garden by Gustafson Porter and Gustafson Guthrie Nichol hidden at the end of the road. You enter into a new garden of paradise, the concept behind GP and GGN 's design. Bean stalks and lettuce heads are sprinkled to your left and straight ahead, a grass field meant for refuge from the dizzying world of design. If the verdant experience doesn't save you, simply look up at a fabric mimiking the clouds, held by weather balloons, giving a graceful dance of white playing with the wind.
Gustafson Porter - Gustafson Guthrie Nichol
Towards Paradise
2008, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
MAD Office
Super Star_A Mobile China Town in Rome
Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
cloud 9
Thirst Pavilion
Expo Saragozza, Spagna 2007, Collezione: cloud 9, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Collectif EXYZT
LABICHAMPI festival
Karosta, Latvia. 2007, Photo: Cyrille Weiner, Credits: EXYZT, Courtesy: EXYZT and Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Elemental
Community design workshop
2007, � Elemental S.A., Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Estudio Teddy Cruz
A housing Urbanism made of waste
Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
Stalker - Osservatorio Nomade
Pratiche spaziali di condivisione
IL TAPPETO VOLANTE, (Campo Boario / Roma 2000), Realizzato con i rifugiati curdi nel Centro socioculturale Ararat, con il sostegno del Ministero degli Affari Esteri e la Fondazione Orestiadi, Gibellina, Courtesy: Fondazione La Biennale di Venezia
The Venice Biennale has an overwhelming presentation of design that is not overly coherent. Forget trying to see it all. Take it in like an Italian workday; expresso, then one hour of exhibit, followed by another espresso and brioche, followed by the next hour, and so on. Or take a break over at the Stalker/ Osservatorio Nomade exhibit and have your I Ching foretold, like architects such as Peter Eisenmann, who I've heard ritually does this. I am taking with me from the Biennale a hazy memory of craft, digitization, urban solutions and a reading of good fortune for the year.
Martina Dolejsova
Martina is an architect and writer currently living in Los Angeles
10 Comments
thanks martina for the great review! I almost feel like I was there, too (which in fact I was...not...boo-hoo...)
great review, i was going to post a thread last night asking if anyone was at the opening weekend. looking fwd to going in mid-october.
Opening week-end nutritional highlights:
10am champagne on rooftop of P. Guggenheim's palazzo, courtesy of the Australians. Vini rossi & French charcuteries in covered courtyard of Querini-Stampalia, for La Défense masterplan exhibit opening. Being offered gorgeous cherry tomatoes in Gustafson Porter's hidden Eden... (best of show). And tornado on Saturday led to many a Spritz...
enjoyed this review very much, thanks!
is it true there was a party for the 'important press' only?
thanks for the reporting. i enjoyed very much.
seems like the whole event was geared toward the groupies with a lot of furniture and 'architect art' of family and friends. specially with the bigger names, the usual suspects.
a cut above the small town trade show but nevertheless, hodgepodge of this and that.
why betsky is curating everything in his 'arsenal?'
convincingly, these events are what they are; 'industry with industry,' unfortunately.
like, cocktails only.
two years from now, it might be a different story. hopefully. with less furniture and installation art by architects.
and, maybe with an outsider curator?
why does every architect installation remind me of a hybridization of sleeper/clockwork orange/ tv star trek??? when will i be able to get my spinach croissant and cappucino in pill form?
When the focus is on Venice again, this year, don't miss THE SECOND VENICE by Askin Ozcan. A fantasy humor about a new Venice built by the real Venice, as the Italian Government limits the number of tourists to it, to protect it from destruction.
ISBN 1598000888 Outskirts Press (Available at the archinect bookshop)
http://www.outskirtspress.com/thesecondvenice
http://compulsivereader.com/html/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=1630
Orhan,
it was quite the event. maybe i crashed that important press party? there seemed to be plenty of 'invitation only'
kind of like going to a rock concert and sneaking in through the gate
nice review, gives a good sense of the offerings. and the guardian review is also very good, giving even more of a sense of the goofiness of what the biennale has become.
i have a weird sense of disjunction reading this back to back with stories of our $700b rescue of moneygame players, the destruction caused by ike, and the mockery that mccain/palin is making of the american election process. the community design and recycling projects seem a little token given that the overall impression of most visitors seems to be 1) party, 2) naked people, and 3) science fiction-ish megastructures. i know, i know, this is not supposed about being relevant but about being curious and exploratory, but...it's just bizarro somehow.
I liked Penezić & Rogina Architect installation called "Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Wolf in Digital Age?". On a very interesting/ironic way architects presented their vision what should be the future of architecture.
http://www.wallpaper.com/architecture/venice-biennale-2008/2668
Click the pictures slide show to view the installation.
Block this user
Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?
Archinect
This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.