Remember when we had to look up a business in the yellow pages? Or when we had to go to the library to learn about a topic of interest? Technological advances, particularly the internet, have drastically changed the way we perform such tasks. Clearly, this has had a profound impact on the way we work. Not only do we have a vast amount of information at our disposal, but that information can be accessed quickly, then managed and organized clearly and efficiently.
For an architecture practice, technology has particularly affected the way designers can specify products and materials. Rather than wading through an office's library of quickly-outdated catalogs, designers these days can search ever-expanding and constantly-updated resources with ease, identifying products from around the world to use in new architecture projects. Designers can connect with representatives, negotiate quotes, and coordinate delivery faster than ever.
Now, the question is where to start. There are several different platforms available to designers these days that help streamline the process of specification. To try to get some insight into the value specification software can offer a firm, and what options are out there, I reached out to my good friend (and, full disclosure, founder of Designer Pages) Jacob Slevin...
Paul Petrunia: So what kind of value does specification software offer a design firm?
Jacob Slevin: The specification process for both architectural and interior design projects is a veritable beast. Or perhaps a clockwork is a better metaphor: an unfathomably complex machine with thousands upon thousands of moving parts, each of differing dimensions and varied functions. When these disparate elements fail to mesh, things can come to a grinding halt, or worse, implode and destruct in a cacophonous grind. Many firms rely on Word or Excel or PowerPoint to perform this gargantuan task of organization and collaboration, but these programs are inadequate, to say the least. I’d like all design pros to know that there are better tools out there, and they WILL save you time, money and effort!
There’s no doubt that architecture and design firms are often over-extended in terms of time and resources. What do you tell firms that question the cost-to-benefit analysis of change?
Don’t get me wrong. I’m not judging and I understand: change is hard. And making such a fundamental alteration to the way things have always been done is a risk, and a time-drain, and a challenge to company morale. But while the learning curve might be a bit steep, the payoff is tremendous. A&D spec software streamlines both architecture and interior design projects. It provides a seamless organization, enables instantaneous and collaborative access to project elements, and facilitates enhanced communication among project participants. In short, it has the potential to put all of the great variety of moving parts into neat columns and straight lines—right there at your disposal to be organized, searched, altered, and replaced. It allows a kind of bird’s eye view of everything (viewable by everybody)—an enhanced perspective from which elements can be seamlessly manipulated, not only improving productivity and efficiency, but also realizing significant cost-savings.
What specification software platforms do you encounter most?
I obviously need to include Designer Pages PRO. It would be unfair of me to say that we’re the best, but I’m obviously very proud of what we’ve accomplished. I’d feel supremely confident stating on the record that any of these solutions below are better than Microsoft Office! With that said, here’s my top five.
Avitru + Deltek’s MasterSpec retains the basic outline of the “Spec Book” while refining it for ease and efficiency. The software allows targeted customization, so users may delete what doesn’t apply while adding their own sections—from a comprehensive database of more than 900 sections organized by practice-specific libraries. All content is written by licensed design professionals. MasterSpec also boasts an industry-leading advisory committee who meet six to eight times each year to advise on content and provide updates. Lastly, the software is confidential, with a strict prohibition of sharing personal or project-identifiable information.
Similarities to original Spec Book enables easy transition
Product of AIA
Customizable with a library of 924 Sections
Completely transparent with clear labeling of any manufacturer-specific content
No sharing of user data
BSD SpecLink’s dynamic interface is constantly updated to current standards and code references. The software also integrates intelligent linking that improves efficiency, minimizing errors while allowing targeted editing by selection. Lastly, the platform is cloud-based, facilitating remote collaboration and coordination among multiple stakeholders.
Cloud-Based platform
Updated standards and code references
Seamless linking with Revit
Automatically synchronized changes
Immersive 3D walkthroughs
Designer Pages PRO is a comprehensive product and material selection tool that streamlines all aspects of the specification process for any commercial interior project: Education, Health & Wellness, Hospitality, Retail, Workplace and more. It’s the only interior specification platform in this list that’s a cloud-based platform, so all designers in the project spectrum can access it anytime, anywhere, from any machine with an internet connection. Designer Pages PRO’s expansive product database is a tremendous time- saver, with filtering options to satisfy specific needs. Designer Pages PRO also makes it easy to create and organize projects based on information such as category, budget, room, and type. The Vendor Directory is another big perk, allowing designers to organize sales rep, further streamlining the spec process. Lastly, it communicates with Revit, both push and pull.
Web-based for easy access and quick collaboration
Database of nearly 10,000 brands and more than 250,000 products for sourcing and specification
HTML/CSS Editor to develop custom PDFs
Bi-Direction Interoperability with Revit
Most affordable spec writing tool
dRofus’ database automatically updates information for all project stakeholders, including owners, architects, engineers, consultants, and FM Handover/Asset Management. The software is particularly nimble at synchronizing the requirements of architects and engineers via a bi-directional connection between dRofus and BIM modeling tools such as Archicad and Revit. This makes it an ideal tool for complex infrastructure and room element needs, as encountered in healthcare projects.
Bi-directional syncing with Archicad and Revit
Customized PDFs and Excel reports
Management of public standards and equipment
Consolidates room data, equipment sheets, and data planning
Seamless transition for FM handover and asset management
Founded in 1999, Specsources is a pioneer of FFE specification writing software. A comprehensive data management and integration tool, Specsources is a virtual, dynamic, cloud-based Spec Book that enables collaboration within and among interior design firms. The company recently launched Version 5: “a faster and easier to use interface with streamlined adding areas/locations function, improved search tools, improved submittal tracking, and more printing options.”
Organize specs by item type, area, manufacturer, room, vendor, issue date, and revision date
Budget reports and master schedule integration
Edit images in software
Built-in Mandarin option
Single-directional synchronization with Revit
---
For a firm that hasn't yet waded into the pool of specification software, which tools would you suggest they start with?
It’s certainly a new age when it comes to specification writing. The above-profiled software represents my favorites of these collaborative tools. I don’t necessarily recommend one over the others, but I do suggest that they fit slightly different niches. For instance, dRofus appears to be a fabulous tool to bridge the gap between architects and building engineers for large-scale projects, but it’s probably not the best tool for interior designers writing project specs. My advice is to understand your spec writing needs, ask around, do some research, and drill down to the tool that will work best for you. But by all means, ditch the Word docs, Excel spreadsheets and PowerPoint presentations and enter the brave new world of spec writing software. You’ll be amazed at the time and money you’ll save, the headaches you’ll forestall, and the clients you’ll impress.
Paul Petrunia is the founder and director of Archinect, a (mostly) online publication/resource founded in 1997 to establish a more connected community of architects, students, designers and fans of the designed environment. Outside of managing his growing team of writers, editors, designers and ...
5 Comments
If you have not been editing specifications for a while and mentored by a seasoned specifier, or have been certified in (at least) Documents Technology by the CSI - you probably shouldn't be messing around doing it. There are lots of Independent Specifiers (SCIP Members) who will take care of your needs. The liability issues for improperly articulated specifications sections is simply too great to risk playing around with that area of our field. A project manual (improperly referred to as the "spec book") is far more than the stuff you pick out for a project. That selection is part 2 of a technical specification, but the other two parts of a technical section are just as important. Project Delivery Systems vary a great deal these days, and the Division 01 Requirements dictate what is designated in your agreement.
However, if you are up to speed on those technical and legal nuances, and are looking at software packages, a couple of things that you should consider are: 1. Ease of use. 2. Editors notes. 3. Publication.
The Deltek software is an edit-out software with multiple editing packages that can be purchased. So what you see on the page has all the selections available, and you delete what you don't want. This is fine if you actually know what the references mean. MasterWorks is the most commonly used editing tool for product MasterSpec, but it is not BIM interoperable. The do offer a plug-in tool that is quite different than MasterWorks.
BSD Spec Link E is an edit-in software. So you select what you want in a particular section instead of what you don't want. One of the things that you will get with the BSD software are some clues (a green light) on items that you should include, clues about things you should consider (a yellow light) you should consider, and a (red light) that tells you that you are in conflict with something you put somewhere else. This includes the Division 01 material (which you should do first in any case). It also contains a fully articulated Design Criteria section (Uniformat) which is very useful in Schematic phase. BIM integration requires purchasing Linkman.
In either case, if you don't know what the OmniClass / Uniformat designations in your Revit Properties Menu mean, these plug ins wont be much used to you.
I don't know much about the smaller dogs in the fight, but the libraries of office masters that are Word Documents wont be around much longer. Cloud Based software is going to become the standard.
jpilus, your summary is a little out of date. BSD doesn't offer or support LinkMan anymore - BIM integration is standard with the cloud version of SpecLink now.
And CSI's CDT is pretty much redundant for anyone who has passed the ARE.
You managed to get me smoking, but no fire yet. I got the free introductory version of SpecLink Cloud a few months ago, but I wasn't really aware that the software that I was currently using would be obsolete in January. I have about a 1/2 billion dollars worth of projects on the board that I have to migrate to the new software. I will reevaluate my judgement about what I like the best once I get my head around the new system.
I used to use BSD Speclink as well and liked it. But like you said, with my being in the earlier years of my career at the time, good mentorship coupled with a seasoned architect checking what I did was the key. The software was just the tool.
No love for Deltek's e-SPECS software, or Chalkline's VisiSpecs?
Really what I want though is a software that can tell me what product "TBD" is supposed to be when I see it in the finish schedule. Can any of these software packages do that?
Block this user
Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?
Archinect
This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.