My local AHJ is demanding radon mitigation pits for the "possibility" there may be an issue "one day" in all our commercial projects. Its crazy, in a shop with 6 pull through bays there is not going to be a build up of radon gasses.
I think the lobbyist are out of control on this one.
Non Sequitur
Dec 12, 18 4:29 pm
I've seen a big increase in radon products & presentations in the last 2 years... as well as heavy marketing in all those dumb do it yourself home renovation shows. My codes require passive radon mitigation in crawl spaces... which is easily achieved by placing a grille in the wall.
Almosthip7
Dec 12, 18 5:19 pm
I live in an area of Canada that Radon is not an issue. Its stupid. Even after presented with a standata that states its up to the professional to decide.
Non Sequitur
Dec 12, 18 11:32 pm
Are they asking for mechanical mitigation?
Almosthip7
Dec 13, 18 10:40 am
No, they approved plans, now are coming back after the slab is poured wondering were is it. I agree its just a pit with poly, crushed fill and a pipe, but the slab has already been poured.
Almosthip7
Dec 13, 18 10:42 am
On a 6 bay pull thru shop with slab on grade and the office portion on a structural slab.
Non Sequitur
Dec 13, 18 11:31 am
We've had AHJ ask for things after the permit docs are approved all the time... but always during construction. We would request in writing what code and or zoning regulation requires the radon dealie and, if they can't produce it in black and white, then issue a letter stating that since it is not a requirement, it was not installed.
Bloopox
Dec 12, 18 4:56 pm
Agreed it's crazy for a space with 6 regularly-used pull through bays.
But radon levels change, so in a less obviously constantly ventilated situation it's not so extremely crazy to design for possibility. Ground saturation or freezing affects test results. So does wind. On a longer-term basis settling of the building can change radon levels, as can surrounding construction, shifting ground conditions, changes in water levels and drainage.
The rock types here make my location prone to radon, so it's pretty normal for the AHJ to require it, though seems less reasonable if you're not in a place with as high a likelihood of excessive levels.
Almosthip7
Dec 12, 18 5:22 pm
I live on silty clay, way more concerned about heaving foundations
than radon
senjohnblutarsky
Dec 12, 18 5:08 pm
It's a hell of a lot easier to put it in now than it will be later...
Almosthip7
Dec 12, 18 5:21 pm
But that cost should be up to the client to decide. Pay a little now or a lot later. I would roll the dice on my 6 bay shop
Peter Normand
Dec 12, 18 6:03 pm
The local Authoraties are asking for it, I would consider how much time and money it would take to appeal this and possibly win them over and consider the lost time for the client's building and then compare that to the cost of complying with the radon mitigation. If you have a lot of potential expense to put this in then it might be worth fighting but if it is a small cost overall and delaying delivery of the building to appeal an AHJ's decision will likely (even if you win) cost the client more than the install of the radon mitigation system then it might be a good idea to put it in and move on. Fighting this might not ad value to the project, but if this is the type of project that will be repeated over and over again like a chain of stores then it might be worth it for the future savings of other projects.
poop876
Dec 12, 18 6:04 pm
We've been doing it for all projects for about 10 years.
arch76
Dec 12, 18 10:27 pm
isnt this just a perforated pvc relief pipe and heavy duty vapor barrier under the slab on grade? do they have more onerous requirements?
Bench
Dec 13, 18 10:50 am
But if the slab on grade is already poured ...
Peter Normand
Dec 13, 18 3:10 pm
Then I hope the architect in question has good insurance as this should have been a know requirement and the architect will be on the hook.
Almosthip7
Dec 13, 18 5:14 pm
I have a standata that states its up to the professional and the plans were already approved by the AHJ.
Non Sequitur
Dec 13, 18 5:25 pm
Are you not the professional?
Almosthip7
Dec 13, 18 5:29 pm
yes that is my whole point
Everyday Architect
Dec 13, 18 5:35 pm
Ask the AHJ to look at the stamp on the drawings. Then ask them if it says their name. Then ask them who the professional is again.
SneakyPete
Dec 13, 18 8:16 pm
End of the day they either issue you an occupancy permit or they don't. If they don't, lawyers get involved.
wurdan freo
Dec 14, 18 12:20 am
thank god for inspectors. They really save the day.
My local AHJ is demanding radon mitigation pits for the "possibility" there may be an issue "one day" in all our commercial projects. Its crazy, in a shop with 6 pull through bays there is not going to be a build up of radon gasses.
I think the lobbyist are out of control on this one.
I've seen a big increase in radon products & presentations in the last 2 years... as well as heavy marketing in all those dumb do it yourself home renovation shows. My codes require passive radon mitigation in crawl spaces... which is easily achieved by placing a grille in the wall.
I live in an area of Canada that Radon is not an issue. Its stupid. Even after presented with a standata that states its up to the professional to decide.
Are they asking for mechanical mitigation?
No, they approved plans, now are coming back after the slab is poured wondering were is it. I agree its just a pit with poly, crushed fill and a pipe, but the slab has already been poured.
On a 6 bay pull thru shop with slab on grade and the office portion on a structural slab.
We've had AHJ ask for things after the permit docs are approved all the time... but always during construction. We would request in writing what code and or zoning regulation requires the radon dealie and, if they can't produce it in black and white, then issue a letter stating that since it is not a requirement, it was not installed.
Agreed it's crazy for a space with 6 regularly-used pull through bays.
But radon levels change, so in a less obviously constantly ventilated situation it's not so extremely crazy to design for possibility. Ground saturation or freezing affects test results. So does wind. On a longer-term basis settling of the building can change radon levels, as can surrounding construction, shifting ground conditions, changes in water levels and drainage.
The rock types here make my location prone to radon, so it's pretty normal for the AHJ to require it, though seems less reasonable if you're not in a place with as high a likelihood of excessive levels.
I live on silty clay, way more concerned about heaving foundations than radon
It's a hell of a lot easier to put it in now than it will be later...
But that cost should be up to the client to decide. Pay a little now or a lot later. I would roll the dice on my 6 bay shop
The local Authoraties are asking for it, I would consider how much time and money it would take to appeal this and possibly win them over and consider the lost time for the client's building and then compare that to the cost of complying with the radon mitigation. If you have a lot of potential expense to put this in then it might be worth fighting but if it is a small cost overall and delaying delivery of the building to appeal an AHJ's decision will likely (even if you win) cost the client more than the install of the radon mitigation system then it might be a good idea to put it in and move on. Fighting this might not ad value to the project, but if this is the type of project that will be repeated over and over again like a chain of stores then it might be worth it for the future savings of other projects.
We've been doing it for all projects for about 10 years.
isnt this just a perforated pvc relief pipe and heavy duty vapor barrier under the slab on grade? do they have more onerous requirements?
But if the slab on grade is already poured ...
Then I hope the architect in question has good insurance as this should have been a know requirement and the architect will be on the hook.
I have a standata that states its up to the professional and the plans were already approved by the AHJ.
Are you not the professional?
yes that is my whole point
Ask the AHJ to look at the stamp on the drawings. Then ask them if it says their name. Then ask them who the professional is again.
End of the day they either issue you an occupancy permit or they don't. If they don't, lawyers get involved.
thank god for inspectors. They really save the day.