There are two areas of my house that I want to put an expansion in and both areas have unique roof situations that I would like some help and possible options on. How might the roof look after modification in these situations?
The first is at the front of the house that looks like so. This requires a bit of finesse to ensure that the front elevation of the house isn't spoiled (for example I can't put another 'California' roof on the new section to create an 'M' shaped roofline from the street.
The size of the expansion is about 5ft depth by ~20ft width
The second is at the back of the house. Less of a 'street view' problem, but odd shaped, hence a different challenge likely.
The depth (from left to right) is ~17ft. The narrow part of the width (from top to bottom) is about 7.5 ft. The full width is ~15 ft.
Any help in terms of generic roof-line options in these situations is greatly appreciated.
The roof is shingle. Rain water valleys would obviously need to be avoided hence the need to avoid an 'M' shaped roof.
Non Sequitur
Sep 2, 20 1:26 pm
have you considered knocking this ugly generic building down and burning the rubble ? More importantly, hire an architect if you want design advice.
tduds
Sep 2, 20 1:33 pm
Mansard.
citizen
Sep 2, 20 5:22 pm
^ It really goes with anything, doesn't it?
Chad Miller
Sep 2, 20 1:43 pm
Hire an architect you cheap bastard.
Go with a tensile and fabric roof .
atelier nobody
Sep 2, 20 2:54 pm
Free "professional" advice is worth what you paid for it, often less.
SneakyPete
Sep 2, 20 3:06 pm
First you must understand what "roof" is.
atelier nobody
Sep 2, 20 3:32 pm
Say to Shingle, "Shingle, what do you want to be?"
tduds
Sep 2, 20 5:27 pm
Sometimes you won't like what the shingle says.
citizen
Sep 2, 20 9:01 pm
To which it replies, "Don't tie me down. I like being shingle."
Donna Sink
Sep 2, 20 10:11 pm
Shingles on a reverse slope? I'm in love!
tduds
Sep 3, 20 11:25 am
It's not aging well, unfortunately.
SpontaneousCombustion
Sep 2, 20 3:38 pm
Public service announcement: This is the work that people hire architects to do. Contact a few and shop around for someone who has a good idea of what you want to do, and a portfolio of relevant past projects. Most will offer an initial consultation free of charge. Of course we do see people attempt do this sort of work for free on this forum, but those people are usually aspiring architect high school students, or unemployed hobbyists with little or no relevant experience.
Jay1122
Sep 2, 20 4:13 pm
Man why would you bother to do a tiny expansion like that. You have to knock down walls, do the footing, the expansion, the window, the roof, and for what? that little area gain? You don't think this is some weekend DIY job do you?
Anyway about the roof, do a low slope liquid applied membrane green roof and put some plants on it. My favorite kind of roof. No gutter, do roof drains. Gutter is sin.
apscoradiales
Sep 2, 20 4:34 pm
Came to the wrong place for advice, huh?
Don't put any roof - be different.
Waterproof the inside of walls and the floor
bowling_ball
Sep 2, 20 6:25 pm
Thatch. It can conform to any shape and as long as you don't mind re-roofing every year, you can probably do it yourself. And you should!
SneakyPete
Sep 2, 20 6:28 pm
If you need more information I know a few good books on the master of the technique Margaret Thatcher.
citizen
Sep 2, 20 7:49 pm
You omitted the critical comma: Margaret, Thatcher.
(And wouldn't she be mistress of the technique?)
SneakyPete
Sep 2, 20 7:55 pm
Next time I dig her up I will ask her.
Donna Sink
Sep 2, 20 10:12 pm
Does thatch really have to be redone every year? I thought they just piled new on top of the old?
atelier nobody
Sep 3, 20 3:27 pm
How often thatch needs to be redone depends on how well it was done in the first place - since in this case it was suggested as a DIY project, annual replacement seems like a reasonable assumption.
Wilma Buttfit
Sep 2, 20 7:50 pm
Hips, gables -- you just pick one. What is a California roof?
citizen
Sep 2, 20 9:40 pm
What else? Fake, in the sense that a secondary gable or other element is not framed integrally, but after-the-fact, as it were.
Wilma Buttfit
Sep 2, 20 10:25 pm
Overframed. Got it. Thanks.
randomised
Sep 3, 20 4:39 am
just continue the roof down and dig a pit for the expansion
lower.case.yao
Sep 3, 20 1:47 pm
Hey, I’m willing to take the sacrifice and bid in this work. Min-wage/hr can PM me.
Hello
There are two areas of my house that I want to put an expansion in and both areas have unique roof situations that I would like some help and possible options on. How might the roof look after modification in these situations?
The first is at the front of the house that looks like so. This requires a bit of finesse to ensure that the front elevation of the house isn't spoiled (for example I can't put another 'California' roof on the new section to create an 'M' shaped roofline from the street.
The size of the expansion is about 5ft depth by ~20ft width
The second is at the back of the house. Less of a 'street view' problem, but odd shaped, hence a different challenge likely.
The depth (from left to right) is ~17ft. The narrow part of the width (from top to bottom) is about 7.5 ft. The full width is ~15 ft.
Any help in terms of generic roof-line options in these situations is greatly appreciated.
The roof is shingle. Rain water valleys would obviously need to be avoided hence the need to avoid an 'M' shaped roof.
have you considered knocking this ugly generic building down and burning the rubble ? More importantly, hire an architect if you want design advice.
Mansard.
^ It really goes with anything, doesn't it?
Hire an architect you cheap bastard.
Go with a tensile and fabric roof .
Free "professional" advice is worth what you paid for it, often less.
First you must understand what "roof" is.
Say to Shingle, "Shingle, what do you want to be?"
Sometimes you won't like what the shingle says.
To which it replies, "Don't tie me down. I like being shingle."
Shingles on a reverse slope? I'm in love!
It's not aging well, unfortunately.
Public service announcement: This is the work that people hire architects to do. Contact a few and shop around for someone who has a good idea of what you want to do, and a portfolio of relevant past projects. Most will offer an initial consultation free of charge. Of course we do see people attempt do this sort of work for free on this forum, but those people are usually aspiring architect high school students, or unemployed hobbyists with little or no relevant experience.
Man why would you bother to do a tiny expansion like that. You have to knock down walls, do the footing, the expansion, the window, the roof, and for what? that little area gain? You don't think this is some weekend DIY job do you?
Anyway about the roof, do a low slope liquid applied membrane green roof and put some plants on it. My favorite kind of roof. No gutter, do roof drains. Gutter is sin.
Came to the wrong place for advice, huh?
Don't put any roof - be different.
Waterproof the inside of walls and the floor
Thatch. It can conform to any shape and as long as you don't mind re-roofing every year, you can probably do it yourself. And you should!
If you need more information I know a few good books on the master of the technique Margaret Thatcher.
You omitted the critical comma: Margaret, Thatcher.
(And wouldn't she be mistress of the technique?)
Next time I dig her up I will ask her.
Does thatch really have to be redone every year? I thought they just piled new on top of the old?
How often thatch needs to be redone depends on how well it was done in the first place - since in this case it was suggested as a DIY project, annual replacement seems like a reasonable assumption.
Hips, gables -- you just pick one. What is a California roof?
What else? Fake, in the sense that a secondary gable or other element is not framed integrally, but after-the-fact, as it were.
Overframed. Got it. Thanks.
just continue the roof down and dig a pit for the expansion
Hey, I’m willing to take the sacrifice and bid in this work. Min-wage/hr can PM me.