Archinect
anchor

textbooks v course readers v ebooks and the internet

It's that time of year again, when university bookstores everywhere start pressuring educators to select texts for the next semester. Since it seems that many of my students this past year didn't even bother to crack open the books the syllabus required them to purchase, I'm struggling with the role of the TEXTBOOK in my courses.

In design eduction, there are a wide range of pedagogical approaches that either require extensive reading or not. The role of readings in studio is probably a separate thread. In theory, much of the subject matter are texts. In history, and technical subjects it can help to have a reference book.

My challenges in picking a book (or two or three) for my seminar include:

First, there are too many options and not enough time to find the best text to supplement my lectures. Even if many publishers provide free 'examination' copies, I don't have time to read them all.

second, none of the books I've looked at, cover all the topics that my lectures explore.

third, I know what it is like to be an impoverished student - books are expensive (especially because the publisher sends out so many free copies to us educators), so I need to justify the value of the book(s).

forth, I hope to find books that will be used beyond my course and become a valued addition to their personal libraries.

So I'm really tempted to pull together a course reader with excerpts from my favorite treatise on the topics that I'm covering. My other choice is to just place all the books on reserve instead of spending $$$$ Course readers can be very expensive if they deal with all the copyrights, but until I write my own book there isn't a single book that covers what I want.

In these days of the ebook and lots of (free) stuff on the internet, is a textbook or course reader even appropriate?

What are your preferences as students, educators, and practitioners?

 
Apr 30, 10 1:10 pm

although i'm a book lover and still have all of the books that i ever bought for my classes, i don't think that requiring students to buy books makes much sense these days... probably the only exception would be for large, introductory lecture courses in history/theory/structures/m&m where the lectures might closely follow a book... for most other courses i think that it is best just to provide scanned PDFs of all of the readings either uploaded to a course folder on the server or on a course website (like blackboard)... this allows students the option of printing them all out or reading on screen... personally, i've never been all that comfortable reading on screen, so i always end up printing everything and essentially creating my own course reader... this is actually one thing that i think the iPad might change since there apparently is a PDF reader app that allows you to easily highlight and comment on PDFs...

Apr 30, 10 1:42 pm  · 
 · 
Carl Douglas (agfa8x)

i make a course reader rather than give a list of books to buy. it gives me more flexibility, and provides students with a number of different styles of writing (writing style is a big barrier for some, I've found)

it often takes a while getting the pdfs together, but once you have them, you can reuse them. like philip, i make them available online.

this doesn't work so well for visually-intensive books or very long texts, where the students would end up printing out hundreds of pages.

i also try to recommend things for students to read as i go. I don't know how many follow up on this, though.

(you can highlight and comment on pdfs in Acrobat Reader or Preview or pretty much any pdf reader, btw)

Apr 30, 10 9:47 pm  · 
 · 
Distant Unicorn

Seriously? JSTOR... for life!

I prefer digital/OCR'd eBooks and articles. The preference I have is, while textbooks can be cited, that college should be prepare you for writing practical articles and papers. It seems once you break the first two or three years of undergrad and start moving into graduate education, everything is all journal entries and secondary references (newspapers et cetera).

I'd imagine for the most part that this applies to architecture as well as it does in urban planning/urban design/economics.

[objectionable]Part of reading a book is too absorb all of the information in that book whether the information is practical or worthwhile to subjects the course is exploring.

That familiarity allows you to recall where in the book and which sections would contain that information if you were referencing it at a later point (i.e., writing papers, synthesis, all that jazz.

While it is good to read books from cover to cover to gain valuable knowledge, it is much easier to just search them with the digital technology we have available. But even with keywords, one still has to read the article found in order to see if the use of the search term is appropriate with the paper.

In this sense, it makes more sense to use 'survey' type books that explore topics and wet someone's appetite in that subject. Once some is engaged by an idea and a topic, it makes searching for information relevant to that topic via JSTOR or Google Scholar.

To an extent, textbooks are fundamentally dead if one is looking for more precise, specialized or peer-reviewed information.[/objectionable]

Apr 30, 10 10:49 pm  · 
 · 
Distant Unicorn

I think an interesting take on the course would be to supply a list of boolean or other search strings to use in JSTOR's or Google Scholar's databases so they can explore course topics that interest them.

Heck... you could even turn it into a weekly assignment where they have to find at least one article a week on the subject list, write an executive summary and give you the summary/printed article.

Think of it as free research building-- you could then compile a book because most of your referencing is half done!

Apr 30, 10 10:52 pm  · 
 · 
CADworld

Looking for Architectural Books and Magazines?

We have a large selection of PDF Format and Bound Printed
Architectural Books and Magazines.

Please feel free to contact us with your requests.

We can deliver the books and magazines by e-mail for PDF format
or by mail for bound printed books and magazines.

Why pay so much for these books in bookstores where these books are severely over-priced! We sell to you under 50% discounted cost. This means you can buy more for your money.

Go ahead and send us an e-mail with your requests.

Hope to hear from all of you soon!

tbag005@gmail.com

May 5, 10 12:25 am  · 
 · 

Block this user


Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site?

Archinect


This is your first comment on Archinect. Your comment will be visible once approved.

  • ×Search in: