Like Archinect on Facebook.
Sign up to our mailing list.
Not sure if I am on right place, but I'm very interested in this topic, so I'll be glad to be informed if I could get some informations about it.
While analysing Moorish architecture, I was stunningly amazed with their vaulted domes. By all informations I could find, first appearance of this form is in Cordoba mosque ( AD 965).
They are soon followed by those in Toledo, in Mosque of Cristo de la Luz (999):
and in Mosque da las Tornerias (middle of 11th century):
Then they appear in Western parts of North Africa, like these in Marakech, Morroco:
Al Koubba dome (1117)
Koutoubia mosque (end of 12th century)
Tlemcen mosque (1136)
I have always been interested in Western vaults, analysed their geometrical and structural nature, and the discovery that medieval Moors used such complex rib vaulting before it even appeared in Europe somehow shaked my understading of development of vault in Western vaulting technique. I immediately drew their geometrical plan and concluded that they first constructed ribs as diagonals inside squared or octagonal bases, than they covered the central constructed space with dome and side ones by elements of groin vaults or similar structures.
I knew that Muslims were generally obsessed with geometry, so it seems logical that in one moment they dared to question its structural abilities instead to imploy it only as a decoration. What I find shocking is that they appear as an already developed form out of nothing (like pure idea), instead of a step-by-step development.
I don't know what are technical limitations and possibilities of this way of design, but I recognize that from the point of intellectual inovation it has remarkable value and meaning.
My question is whether it is possible that these domes influenced development of rib vaulting in West and could they somehow influence Gothic architecture?
Interesting quest. I'm no expert, but I'll offer some pointers that may lead to further 'discoveries.'
Arch of Janus Quadrifrons, Rome, c. 315
According to Banister Fletcher, "It has a simple cross-vault with embedded brick box-ribs at the groins, affording a further instance of the progressive charcter of Roman constructive techniques: such ribs are possibly the prototypes of Gothic ribbed vaults."
The Roman Empire of the early 300s was more Eastern centric than Rome centric, with the emperors having more government centers in Asia Minor and Northern Europe than at Rome. For example, Diocletian (c. 300) ruled from Nicomedia (Izmet, Turkey), and before Constantine founded Constantinople (c. 330), he ruled two decades from Treves (Trier, Germany), having spent only about a total of two months in Rome over the course of 30 years. The point being there was a lot of back and forth between Northern Europe and Asia Minor, bringing about a 'cultural exchange' moving mostly from East to West. The Romanesque style very much grew out of this Eastern influence.
I'd try to do a parallel chronology of Moorish architecture and Romanesque architecture. I think you'll start finding similarities, with the Moorish evolving much quicker into elaborate vaulting and the Romanesque striving toward greater and greater height.
you mention Muslims. like everything else, there is a complex history there that goes beyond a pretend religious insularity. Islamic extension (al-mad al-islami) first reached the Syrian lands where overlapped Byzantine Christianity with a hoard of other eastern churches and religious traditions reflecting the myriad regional and historical interfaces with the region (Sassanid, Egyptian, Yemenite, greco-roman, Byzantine...etc). The establishment of the first Islamic empire, the Ummayad's, incorporated these elements including those architectural. it would thus be incorrect to try and posit a solely western or eastern, Christian or Islamic history either in the context of architecture or indeed in the larger history of people. Let us not forget that Byzantine history itself included a tradition of iconoclasm and the empire was ruled on two occasions by iconodules. Thus a geometric cross fertilisation is very feasible in place of a mainstream figural one although if I recall correctly Byzantine iconoclasm might have been instated in Byzantium after Islamic iconoclasm was instated in syria-palestina. Anyway, the ummayads then spread outwards from damascus to north africa (with its own rich admixture of mediterranean, berber and african cultures) and thereafter reaching Iberian lands. This is the origin of the Moorish Arabs.
So, if you were to take seriously this interest you have, the best route is to trace trajectories of travel and influence across cultures, lands and religions as opposed to limiting yourself to fake dichotomies (west and east, Christianity and Islam, Europeans and Arabs). In fact, did you know that a culturally rich period of the ancient Roman history was presided over by Syrians (septimus Severus and family) and that the very first Roman emperor to be sympathetic to the spread of Christianity was Phillip the Arab? And the history of Islamhas its fair share of blonde northeners and Europeans.
To reiterate some of what tammuz said: It is a challenging, but fun quest and as your (hopefully unbiased) curiosity digs deeper into the archeology of this architectural typology you will find it is due to a lot of cultural cross-breeding spanning Northern Africa, the Iberian peninsula, Mediterranean, Near East, et al. (which by the way are Western classifications).
Might be a spoiler alert, but in my past searching I have not come to the conclusion that the intricate designs, whether they be structural or not, are not from pure idea. Quite the opposite, actually.
Also, another interesting thing about domes is how they resolved the cube (square) to dome (circle) transition.
Thank You for your comments, suggestions and wishes.
As I am informed, groin vault was first used by Romans and became widespread in Romanesque architecture, earlier churches being mostly vaulted (if they were vaulted at all) with simple barrel vaults. It was also used in Byzantine architecture, mostly for galleries, and sometimes it involved a more complicated outline (for instance, when octagonal galleries surounding the dome space were layed on them, it was necessary to cover a non-squared space by adding the third vault-element on the wider side, like in San Vitale in Ravenna. In Charlemagne's Palatine Chapel, simplified solution was used: between squared spaces there were triangle-shaped spaces with kind of a groin vault matching its shape).
I didn't actually mean that they invented groin or ribbed vault, but I am questioning idea that somehow they influenced the concept of complex vaults, ie. "creativity" in vault design that appears later in Gothic architecture. What I cannot find is predecessor nor succesor of this form, because I don't know for any method of "rounding" the square shape of the domed space except pendentives and squinches (with their variants) used before them. I wouldn't say at all that the origin od these is Middle-Eastern, because Islamic domes of those areas resemble earlier Byzantine, Roman, Syriac and Persian domes (simple-structured oval domes laying on pendentives or squinches), and it remained like that long after these Moorish domes appear (they were actually never introduced to Middle East).
Also, they don't seem to have any direct succesor, because no one inherited the form, it just "died" with them. I only found an information on the Internet (though I'm suspicious about that) that they were studied by Brunelleschi in 1402.
(it's in Spanish)
What, let me say so, "drives me crazy" is how they came to combine vaults, ribs (sc. arches) and domes in same form? I will surely continue in research.
P. S. I'm not biased, nor unaware of the fact of cultural exchange. I realise that similar architectural forms and elements were used by different countries, religions and civilisations. I call those domes "Moorish" because they seem to appear only in their buildings, and I speculated "Islamic" influence because geometrical design was highly appreciated in Islamic Art, at least in decoration (actually, square-to-circle patterns are often imployed as decorative elements in mosques).